False Start

Pluckebaum stumbles, but it’s not too late

By Amy Gardner
December 2025

Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum has represented East Sacramento and Downtown for one year. It’s time to question his commitment to his constituents and his job.

During last year’s campaign, I was in Pluckebaum’s corner. I attended debates, canvassed voters and invited Phil into my home to meet neighbors and hear the issues they faced. I was glad when he won.

I watched how things were going, reached out to his office when problems arose and checked in with neighbors. I gave Phil the benefit of the doubt, hoping he’d get up to speed and become the leader we elected.

A year later, I’m concerned about his interest in the job.

District 4 is dynamic. It includes the Capitol and Downtown, countless government offices, large and small businesses, Golden 1 Center, nightlife, cultural events, the city animal shelter and beautiful parks. Its neighborhoods are diverse, from rows of Victorians to new apartments.

The district needs a City Council representative who embraces all these elements and creates a thriving environment. It’s time for Pluckebaum to step up and do the job we expect. So far, that’s not what the community sees from him.

Phil, I encourage you to view your position as if it were a cottage business. Here’s what needs to happen:

—Hire a full team. You’ve limped along with only two staffers. It’s time to bring your staff on par with other councilmembers. Hire people with specialization in areas you lack experience in, people who will help you lead effectively.

—Market your council role. Your website lacks information about you, your staff and resources available to constituents. Make your website the first stop for residents when they need assistance from City Hall. Such as: What if you get bit by a dog? What if you have a homeless camp in front of your business? How to help people struggling with food insecurity? Post this information on your website and refer people to it.

—Market your availability. Use social media. Tell us when you hold town halls, coffee get-togethers or park cleanups. Let residents know when they can meet you, work alongside you and learn how you serve them.

—Communicate. When someone emails, calls or texts, respond quickly. Refer the information to your district staff or city representatives. And follow up.

—Stand up for us. Your comments at council meetings are lackluster. You haven’t stood up for a specific issue, championed any policy change or formed alliances to further your goals.

—Ask for help. Your constituents live through a lot of issues your office is supposed to address. We want you to succeed. Many of us can give you great advice, political support and presence at council meetings. Tell us how we can help you. We will show up.

—Give back to our community. Lead a holiday toy drive. Host entertainment for Run to Feed the Hungry. Champion programs such as Pops in the Park.

These items may sound simple but putting them in place will make your job easier and give you more success.
We want to see you out and about with us. We want you to respond to our concerns, champion our causes and fight for a safer, more vibrant district. The elements for your success are right here. Let’s get them working.

Amy Gardner is a founding member of Midtown-East Sac Advocates. She can be reached at sacwalksafe@gmail.com.